PDA

View Full Version : Genovar's Will Be Jazzy Again Despite Holdups


thelakelander
12-05-2005, 12:42 AM
http://www.jacksonville.com/images/120505/105794_300.jpg

By MARY KELLI PALKA
The Times-Union

In its heyday of the 1940s, the building at Ashley and Jefferson streets in downtown Jacksonville hosted musical performances by jazz greats Louis Armstrong and Billie Holiday.

More than $715,000 in city and state money and five years has been invested in renovating Genovar's Hall, but today the building looks old and decrepit. The most noticeable features now are the large steel posts surrounding the outside of the gutted shell.

"I think it's coming together, but it's taking a lot longer than anyone wanted it to," said City Councilman Reggie Fullwood, who has been a supporter of the restoration project.

The Nu Beta Sigma chapter of Phi Beta Sigma Fraternity Inc. had hoped to restore the three-story building back to its old glory and in the process help revitalize the LaVilla neighborhood that is home to Genovar's Hall.

But fraternity members said the city has delayed the process by withholding grant money for longer than necessary. City officials said they were just trying to iron out some details over use of the building.

Fraternity members are waiting for $100,000 from the city they were promised a couple years ago. They're also asking for an extension on the deadline to finish the building.

"It's a white elephant now, but it'll be a jewel in the crown once it's completed," fraternity President Prentis Clayton said.

He still does not know how much the project will cost to complete. But the fraternity is also looking for private sources of funding.

In 1998, the fraternity started working with the city on a deal to renovate the building, then in the city's surplus property inventory. In March 2000, the city gave the property deed to the fraternity at no cost. The project was supposed to be completed within two years.

The city has given the fraternity about $229,000 in grants to help with the work. The fraternity has also spent about $487,000 in state historical and environmental grants on the project.

In 2003, the fraternity sought an extension on its deadline through April 28. The council approved the extension in January 2004, but the contract between the city and fraternity didn't get signed until March 9, 2005.

In a letter dated March 10, fraternity member and attorney Reginald Estell asked for another extension through Oct. 31 to complete the exterior work.

That new deadline was never agreed to, but the city and fraternity have been working on a new deal since the March letter.

Both sides blame the other for the delay in reaching a new deal. City attorney Tim Dunham said Estell had been slow since August to respond to the city's questions. Estell informed the city it was the increased demands from the February Super Bowl and the General Counsel's Office being short-staffed that delayed a new contract.

Clayton said he doesn't think the city has purposely attempted to delay the project.

Under a draft agreement in the works, the city would be able to use the second floor of the building through 2013 for recreational and meeting space, as well as special events and conferences. The fraternity has plans to turn another portion of the building into a jazz-themed restaurant.

The draft also calls for an extension through next Aug. 31 for exterior work and Aug. 31, 2008, for the completion of the interior.

Mayor John Peyton's office has been working on extending the project deadlines in deference to Fullwood, Chief of Staff Steve Diebenow said.

When asked whether the administration thought the project was important to the revitalization of LaVilla, Diebenow didn't answer. He said Peyton is deferring to Fullwood because the councilman believes it's an important project.

"We're doing it because Reggie asked us to," Diebenow said.

Diebenow said he has seen improvement on the project.

"You can certainly see by driving by that there's a roof on it, that the site has been cleared and that there has been work that's gone on there," Diebenow said. "I think when the project originally started it was just crumbled facades."

On Thursday, the fraternity filed its annual report to the Florida Division of Corporations. It hadn't been filed on time in September, but the city said it needed to be updated prior to the fraternity receiving more grant money.

mary.palkajacksonville.com, (904) 359-4104

This story can be found on Jacksonville.com at http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stor..._20477056.shtml (http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/120505/met_20477056.shtml).

RiversideGator
12-05-2005, 10:28 AM
If I were the City, I would want to know what happened with the first $715,000 on this project before I gave out any additional money. There is an amazing lack of progress for such an amount to have been spent. I am guessing some money was spent on kegs rather than restoration. Still, this is a worthy project and should be completed. The question is though, who should pay for it?

Jim
12-05-2005, 10:54 AM
Whoa, they gave money to a fraternity yet are hesitant on giving money to well established and respected entities?

thelakelander
12-05-2005, 11:06 AM
$715,000 is a lot of money to spent only on what is still currently an empty shell of a building. THis sounds like a worthwhile project, but I would also like to know what is pushing the costs up so high?

Jim
12-05-2005, 11:13 AM
Maybe LandMar will take over this one too......

thelakelander
12-05-2005, 11:14 AM
Lol, I think LandMar's got their hands full with the Shipyards. If they don't hurry up with something, they may get left out in the cold, as far as the downtown luxury condo market goes. Nevertheless, this is another reason why there needs to be a master development plan done for LaVilla. You got this thing going up and a similar project, in the LaVilla Grill going up a couple of blocks away, as well as the recently announced loft project around the corner. So what's going up in between? More compatible entertainment or residents uses maybe?

.....No, how about a brand spanking new homeless shelter.

RiversideGator
12-05-2005, 03:28 PM
Maybe we could change the name of downtown to "Homelessville".

thelakelander
01-08-2006, 04:06 AM
GENOVAR'S HALL: Time to refocus

The shell of a brick building secured by steel beams at Jefferson and Ashley streets downtown betrays a lively history.

Sounds from music legends Louis Armstrong, Billie Holliday, Cab Calloway, Ray Charles and Ella Fitzgerald filled the former jazz hot spot during its 1930s and '40s heydays.

The LaVilla neighborhood reigned as the center of Jacksonville's African-American culture with a nightlife reminiscent of New Orleans' Bourbon Street.

Those times are long left to memories and history books.

In the name of progress and wiping out blight, the city leveled most of LaVilla's defining structures and architecture in the 1990s.

Genovar's Hall -- that once-swinging club with other lives as a grocery, saloon and hotel -- barely survived as a gutted hint of its former self.

But the Nu Beta Sigma Chapter of Phi Beta Sigma Fraternity Inc. envisions a rebirth for Genovar's Hall as offices, meeting space and a restaurant.

For more than a decade, the fraternity has wanted to restore the building as a testimony to LaVilla's heritage.

Fraternity President Prentis Clayton would like to see a renovated building become the anchor for an entire historic block, including a LaVilla museum and perhaps a special memorial for Jacksonville's black veterans.

But just getting the building overhauled has been a struggle.

The city started working with the fraternity in 1998 to revamp the city-owned property, deeding it to Nu Beta Sigma in 2000 at no cost. The goal: Complete the project in two years.

Five years later, the fraternity has spent more than $229,000 in city money and another $487,000 in state historical and environmental grants toward the rehab.

So far, progress has been slow. Deadlines have been missed. The fraternity has submitted accounts to the city on how the money has been spent, which records show was mostly for demolition, steel work and design.

The mayor's administration at one point threatened to take back the property as allowed under the city's contract. But City Council member Reggie Fullwood urged more time for the fraternity.

A proposal promoted by Fullwood would give the fraternity $100,000 more toward the project, requiring the exterior work be done by Aug. 31 and the interior work finished by Aug. 31, 2008.

The additional money would be released based on completion of work.

Clayton said work continues to progress at the site, with the beams used to hold up the building being removed soon.

The fraternity's desire to preserve an important symbol of Jacksonville's past is a noble one, and the group appears to be well intended.

But the project raises big flags for taxpayers.

For instance, the fraternity and the city have not nailed how much it will cost to finish the project or precisely where the remaining money will come from.

Rehabs of historic structures can cost millions. They are challenging enough for experienced developers, let alone social organizations driven by volunteers with other full-time jobs. In addition, material costs are on the rise.

Before committing more city money, the players in this effort -- such as the fraternity, its contractors, the mayor's administration, City Council members, state lawmakers and members of the preservation community -- should meet to reassess and refocus.

They should define the project's progress and costs, where it should go and how it can get there.

Preserving Jacksonville's history should be a high priority. Too many symbols of our past slipped into oblivion over the years -- particularly in LaVilla.

We're rooting for the project to succeed.

But preservation involving public resources should be done the proper way. That's thoughtfully with a solid business plan and taxpayer interests in mind.

This story can be found on Jacksonville.com at http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stor..._20752031.shtml (http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/010806/opi_20752031.shtml).

Jim
01-08-2006, 11:53 AM
I do like the fact this group of younger citizens is really doing all they can to preserve a piece of history despite the damning efforts by the city in the 90's to remove it all.

HEIGHTS UNKNOWN
01-09-2006, 09:07 AM
Originally posted by RiversideGator@Dec 5 2005, 03:28 PM
Maybe we could change the name of downtown to "Homelessville".
That's not funny; it could be you!

RiversideGator
01-09-2006, 01:21 PM
Originally posted by HEIGHTS UNKNOWN+Jan 9 2006, 09:07 AM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (HEIGHTS UNKNOWN @ Jan 9 2006, 09:07 AM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-RiversideGator@Dec 5 2005, 03:28 PM
Maybe we could change the name of downtown to "Homelessville".
That's not funny; it could be you! [/b][/quote]
HEIGHTS UNKNOWN: I wasnt making fun of the homeless. I was refering to the unusual practice in Jacksonville of, on the one hand, encouraging downtown development and encouraging people to move to the city and, on the other hand, also allowing multiple homeless shelters to be operated downtown, the occupants of which tend to scare off the very people we are trying to attract downtown. This policy makes no sense to me. I do think there should be homeless shelters for down on their luck people and families. I also think the mentally ill and drug/alcohol addicts should be cared for in treatment facilities. I just dont believe these facilities should be located in the center of downtown. This is all I meant.

thelakelander
01-09-2006, 01:49 PM
I agree. To this date, I still think the best place for homeless shelters would be a former industrial area like the Dennis Street area or the old warehouses along Mrytle, between I-95 and Beaver St. Both are centrally located in the city, but far enough away to limit their negative effect on the revitalization of downtown.